diff --git a/test/test_traversal.py b/test/test_traversal.py
index 52ea19fab..bc433029d 100644
--- a/test/test_traversal.py
+++ b/test/test_traversal.py
@@ -481,7 +481,7 @@ def test_subs_list_to_dict(self):
             'id': 'name',
             'data': 'content',
             'url': 'url',
-        }, all, {subs_list_to_dict}]) == {
+        }, all, {subs_list_to_dict(lang=None)}]) == {
             'de': [{'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de.ass'}],
             'en': [{'data': 'content'}],
         }, 'subs with mandatory items missing should be filtered'
@@ -507,6 +507,54 @@ def test_subs_list_to_dict(self):
             {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/en1', 'ext': 'ext'},
             {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/en2', 'ext': 'ext'},
         ]}, '`quality` key should sort subtitle list accordingly'
+        assert traverse_obj([
+            {'name': 'de', 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de.ass'},
+            {'name': 'de'},
+            {'name': 'en', 'content': 'content'},
+            {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/en'},
+        ], [..., {
+            'id': 'name',
+            'url': 'url',
+            'data': 'content',
+        }, all, {subs_list_to_dict(lang='en')}]) == {
+            'de': [{'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de.ass'}],
+            'en': [
+                {'data': 'content'},
+                {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/en'},
+            ],
+        }, 'optionally provided lang should be used if no id available'
+        assert traverse_obj([
+            {'name': 1, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de1'},
+            {'name': {}, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de2'},
+            {'name': 'de', 'ext': 1, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de3'},
+            {'name': 'de', 'ext': {}, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de4'},
+        ], [..., {
+            'id': 'name',
+            'url': 'url',
+            'ext': 'ext',
+        }, all, {subs_list_to_dict(lang=None)}]) == {
+            'de': [
+                {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de3'},
+                {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de4'},
+            ],
+        }, 'non str types should be ignored for id and ext'
+        assert traverse_obj([
+            {'name': 1, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de1'},
+            {'name': {}, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de2'},
+            {'name': 'de', 'ext': 1, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de3'},
+            {'name': 'de', 'ext': {}, 'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de4'},
+        ], [..., {
+            'id': 'name',
+            'url': 'url',
+            'ext': 'ext',
+        }, all, {subs_list_to_dict(lang='de')}]) == {
+            'de': [
+                {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de1'},
+                {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de2'},
+                {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de3'},
+                {'url': 'https://example.com/subs/de4'},
+            ],
+        }, 'non str types should be replaced by default id'
 
     def test_trim_str(self):
         with pytest.raises(TypeError):
diff --git a/yt_dlp/utils/traversal.py b/yt_dlp/utils/traversal.py
index 6bb52050f..76b51f53d 100644
--- a/yt_dlp/utils/traversal.py
+++ b/yt_dlp/utils/traversal.py
@@ -332,14 +332,14 @@ class _RequiredError(ExtractorError):
 
 
 @typing.overload
-def subs_list_to_dict(*, ext: str | None = None) -> collections.abc.Callable[[list[dict]], dict[str, list[dict]]]: ...
+def subs_list_to_dict(*, lang: str | None = 'und', ext: str | None = None) -> collections.abc.Callable[[list[dict]], dict[str, list[dict]]]: ...
 
 
 @typing.overload
-def subs_list_to_dict(subs: list[dict] | None, /, *, ext: str | None = None) -> dict[str, list[dict]]: ...
+def subs_list_to_dict(subs: list[dict] | None, /, *, lang: str | None = 'und', ext: str | None = None) -> dict[str, list[dict]]: ...
 
 
-def subs_list_to_dict(subs: list[dict] | None = None, /, *, ext=None):
+def subs_list_to_dict(subs: list[dict] | None = None, /, *, lang='und', ext=None):
     """
     Convert subtitles from a traversal into a subtitle dict.
     The path should have an `all` immediately before this function.
@@ -352,7 +352,7 @@ def subs_list_to_dict(subs: list[dict] | None = None, /, *, ext=None):
     `quality`  The sort order for each subtitle
     """
     if subs is None:
-        return functools.partial(subs_list_to_dict, ext=ext)
+        return functools.partial(subs_list_to_dict, lang=lang, ext=ext)
 
     result = collections.defaultdict(list)
 
@@ -360,10 +360,16 @@ def subs_list_to_dict(subs: list[dict] | None = None, /, *, ext=None):
         if not url_or_none(sub.get('url')) and not sub.get('data'):
             continue
         sub_id = sub.pop('id', None)
-        if sub_id is None:
-            continue
-        if ext is not None and not sub.get('ext'):
-            sub['ext'] = ext
+        if not isinstance(sub_id, str):
+            if not lang:
+                continue
+            sub_id = lang
+        sub_ext = sub.get('ext')
+        if not isinstance(sub_ext, str):
+            if not ext:
+                sub.pop('ext', None)
+            else:
+                sub['ext'] = ext
         result[sub_id].append(sub)
     result = dict(result)